Shop Online!
A selection of our baked goodness is available online!
Visit our online shop and have us mail you something delicious.

Shop In-Store!
Stop by and visit the bakery for the full list of goodies!

COOKIES, ETC. 
$2.50 each, $13/half dozen, $24/dozen

i heart chocolate chips
classic tollhouse
co-operative cherry chocolate chip bar
chocolate XO
everything oatmeal
old school oatmeal raisin
Sonia's grandma's molasses crinkles
peanut butter chocolate chip heaven
the best peanut butter
hemp flax granola cakes
Lauren's snickerdoodles
iced cut-outs
gluten-free ginger spice
gluten-free cranberry almond
gluten-free chocolate chip
gluten-free fudge brownies

MUFFINS
$2.95 each, $15.50/half dozen, $29.50/dozen

pumpkin walnut
marry me blueberry
banana chocolate chip
banana walnut
cranberry orange

WHOOPIE PIES 
$3.25 each, $17.50/half dozen, $33.50 dozen

original
mint
peanut butter
chocolate
pumpkin

CUPCAKES 
$3.95 each, $21/ half dozen, $39.50 dozen

thrilla vanilla
seriously good chocolate
carrot cake
lovely lemon

GRANOLA
$6.75/ pound

peanut butter
maple nut
ginger pecan

OTHER GOODIES

cashew cardamom date truffles $1.50
buckeye bars $2.75
raw "live" cheesecake $5.95
Saturday sticky buns $3.95-$4.95

 

 

CAKE
Come in to Pattycake or call 614-784-2253 to place your order for one of our in-house 6" cakes, or with 3 days notice choose a delectable combination from the selections below.

CLASSIC CAKES

Choose from our basic cake and icing flavors:
chocolate, vanilla, lemon, orange, mint, almond, coconut,
caramel, spice

4" round smash cake... $20
6" round... $30
1/4 sheet... $40
9" round... $50
1/2 sheet... $70
full sheet... $130

CLASSIC CUPCAKES

dozen party size... $30
dozen baby size... $20

DELUXE CAKES
Upgrade your basic cake and icings with one of these delicious flavors: 
peanut butter, strawberry, raspberry, cherry, blackberry, lime, lime coconut, pineapple, pistachio rosewater, apple butter, maple, cookies and cream, Mexican chocolate, mocha, German chocolate, carrot, banana, pumpkin, lavender, marble, chai

size servings price
4" round smash cake... $25
6" round ... $35
1/4 sheet... $50
9" round... $60
1/2 sheet... $85
full sheet... $150

DELUXE CUPCAKES

dozen party size... $40
dozen baby size... $25

Alternate sizes and flavors, torted layers, and gluten-free options are available. 

Please call 614-784-2253 and we will be pleased to consult with you to make your perfect cake.